2 years after Greece’s deadliest prepare crash, victims await solutions : NPR
Wrecked wagons and mangled items of metallic are seen close to the tracks after a prepare accident within the Tempi Valley close to Larissa, Greece, March 1, 2023.
SAKIS MITROLIDIS/AFP by way of Getty Pictures
disguise caption
toggle caption
SAKIS MITROLIDIS/AFP by way of Getty Pictures
ATHENS and THESSALONIKI, Greece — Evdokia Tsagli remembers laughing moments earlier than her prepare wagon spun via the air. The ordeal lasted seven seconds. For Tsagli, “It was like eternity.”
“I believe I stated over 100 occasions to myself, ‘When is it gonna cease?'” she remembers.
On Feb. 28, 2023, her carriage in a Greek passenger prepare landed on prime of the eating automotive forward, flames consuming the wreckage. The prepare, carrying tons of — a lot of them college college students — collided head-on with a freight prepare in Tempi Valley.
It was Greece’s deadliest railway catastrophe. Fifty-seven individuals died. Now, new proof means that many could not have been killed by the crash itself, however by a hearth that adopted.
Greek officers shortly blamed the crash on human error, attributing the hearth to silicone-based cooling oil. However two years later, victims’ households and unbiased investigators say that rationalization does not maintain.
“We’re speaking a few collection of crimes,” says Tsagli, who managed to flee the prepare by climbing via a damaged window and climbing all the way down to security. She and different survivors, together with specialists employed by victims’ households, blame authorities negligence and accuse authorities of a cover-up, one thing the federal government denies. Huge protests are anticipated to deliver elements of the nation to a halt on Friday, the second anniversary of the tragedy.
Arrival of passengers rescued from the railway accident involving a collision between a cargo and a passenger prepare, at Thessaloniki Railway Station, Greece, on March 1, 2023.
KONSTANTINOS TSAKALIDIS/AFP by way of Getty Pictures
disguise caption
toggle caption
KONSTANTINOS TSAKALIDIS/AFP by way of Getty Pictures
“I’ve little or no oxygen”
A newly analyzed name made to the nationwide Greek emergency quantity on the evening of the crash has been fueling recent protests towards the Greek authorities and the non-public and public railway firms concerned within the crash. Within the recording, a passenger might be heard saying: “I’ve little or no oxygen.”
Forensic investigator Vasilis Kokotsakis, employed by victims’ households, says the audio — together with evaluation of video footage displaying the precise second of the collision from exterior the trains — suggests an estimated 30 passengers initially survived the crash, however then had been burned alive.
Primarily based on their evaluation of photographic proof and chemical traces suggesting the presence of business solvents within the soil on the crash website, his crew believes undeclared, extremely flammable chemical cargo — seemingly carried by the freight prepare, although there is no such thing as a method to know for certain — ignited on affect, making a fireball that engulfed a number of passenger vehicles.
The hearth reached temperatures of as much as 1,300 levels Celsius, Kokotsakis says, sufficient to burn victims past recognition. Specialists in hearth issues and chemistry say this destruction can’t be defined by the declare that transformer oil brought on the hearth.
College students participate in protest in Athens towards delays in an investigation into the Tempi prepare accident that killed 57 individuals in 2023, Feb. 7.
Costas Baltas/Anadolu by way of Getty Pictures
disguise caption
toggle caption
Costas Baltas/Anadolu by way of Getty Pictures
Allegations of a cover-up
Households and specialists accuse the federal government of suppressing key proof, claiming no forensic crew documented the crash website earlier than particles elimination.
“Nothing was executed accurately from the start,” Kokotsakis says.
In response to Kokotsakis, not less than 750 cubic meters of soil had been excavated from the crash website and dumped miles away, whereas the wreckage was moved to a different website.
The federal government has argued that the swift elimination of particles and soil was essential to stabilize the world, stop new hazards and resume railway operations.
Extremely sought surveillance footage of the cargo prepare vanished, then resurfaced two years later. In response to a picture evaluation skilled on Kokotsakis’ crew, it was seemingly tampered with. Audio recordings of the conductor’s change with the management room seem edited, additionally in line with Kokotsakis’ crew, to shift blame from higher-level officers and systemic failures to the native station grasp.
“Both we’re speaking about extraordinary incompetence or a concerted effort to cover one thing,” says Nikos Passas, a criminology professor at Northeastern College who’s finding out the crash as a specialist on corruption in Greece and isn’t concerned with the investigation instigated by the victims’ households.
Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis has additionally confronted accusations by critics, together with opposition leaders and victims’ households, of interfering within the judicial investigation into the crash, fueling public mistrust.
The Greek authorities has persistently denied any cover-up or mishandling of the investigation. It didn’t reply to NPR’s questions for touch upon the allegations of negligence and a cover-up.
The leaked emergency name, unbiased forensic findings and perceived missteps by the federal government have fueled public skepticism. A latest ballot discovered 72% of Greeks consider there was a cover-up.
The scene of a rail accident involving a collision between a cargo and a passenger prepare within the Evangelismos space of Larissa, Greece, on March 1, 2023.
STRINGER/SOOC/AFP by way of Getty Pictures
disguise caption
toggle caption
STRINGER/SOOC/AFP by way of Getty Pictures
A sample of negligence and impunity?
Passas says the Tempi crash was a part of a broader sample of corruption in Greece. Regardless of European Union funding meant to modernize railways, crucial security methods had been by no means totally applied. Distant management and signaling know-how might have prevented the crash, however crucial upgrades by no means materialized, in line with railway specialists, unions and opposition officers.
Rail employees had issued repeated warnings about security dangers however claimed considerations had been ignored. Following the tragedy, then-Transport Minister Kostas Karamanlis tendered his resignation, acknowledging the persistent points affecting the railway system. He highlighted the inherited challenges from earlier administrations, noting that his authorities had obtained a railway system in a situation “incompatible with twenty first century requirements.”
The European Public Prosecutor’s Workplace — tasked, in line with its web site, with “investigating, prosecuting and bringing to judgment crimes towards the monetary pursuits” of the European Union — tried to research former transport ministers’ roles within the catastrophe, however the Greek ruling occasion blocked it.
Investigators with the Greek unbiased authority accountable for probing severe transportation accidents on Thursday issued a long-awaited report, which concluded the crash resulted partially from longstanding railway deficiencies and systemic infrastructural points, a few of which stay unresolved and have to be addressed with a view to stop one other tragedy.
The report by the Nationwide Group for the Investigation of Aviation and Railway Accidents and Transport Security additionally acknowledged the prevalence of fire-related deaths, however set the quantity at as much as seven people — far decrease than the estimate by Kokotsakis’ crew. It additionally factors out shortcomings within the crash website investigation, noting that important forensic evaluation and mapping weren’t performed.
“This combat has change into my life’s goal”
Mistrust in official investigations has pushed households to hunt solutions on their very own. Impartial specialists, together with Kokotsakis, have spent months reconstructing the occasions. Within the month because the audio was made public, the phrase “I’ve little or no oxygen” has change into a rallying cry in demonstrations demanding accountability.
Below rising strain and renewed protests, Prime Minister Mitsotakis not too long ago walked again his earlier claims that the freight prepare concerned within the crash was not carrying any hazardous or unlawful materials. In a prolonged interview in late January with Greek media, he stated “all potentialities stay open.”
For victims’ households, that admission is just too little, too late. Some at the moment are pushing for European courts to take up the case, claiming they mistrust the Greek justice system to make sure accountability.
Christos Konstantinidis, who misplaced his spouse within the crash, has spent two years demanding justice. “I’ve reached the purpose the place I’m neglecting my household, the place I’ve deserted my job,” he says. “This combat has change into my life’s goal.”
